Saw it last night. Lots to say.
First, I do need to describe an exacting ritual I undertake with movies I care a lot about. Recently, it's been pretty much just for Star Wars, although I think maybe some Marvel movies fit in here as well.
And the ritual is: Zero information. None. No trailers. No movie posters. No "rumor" articles before it comes out. No toys. No toy commercials. No interviews.
The amount of effort it takes nowadays to NOT see something is incredible. And it's usually incredibly annoying to those with me, who see me averting my eyes on a regular basis like I am avoiding a horde of basilisk.
Back to Star Wars. It's been a long and bumpy road for us Star Wars fans. I'll never forget the excitement of when Episode I came out (soon to be extinguished), or how delightfully surprised I was when Rogue One turned out to be excellent.
I'll admit that my expectations were low. It begins with the famed "A Long Time Ago in a Galaxy Far Far Away" in that magical blue font, and the trumpets calling forth John William's majestic intro. I didn't feel the awe they were going for - there's only so many times you can be stirred by the same spectacle.
As the movie unfolded, I started writing this review in my head. I tried to think of the most succinct summary.
I think it might be: "This may be the
I take no joy in saying that. I don't enjoy crapping on beloved franchises for no reason. And I know this is the era of hyperbole and over-indulging in throw-away phrases like "the worst EVER." Undoubtedly the prequels were ineffective, amateurish and lacked any real spark or impactful storytelling. But I think this movie is a bigger letdown, even while the professionalism may have increased and Jar Jar is pleasant absent.
Here's my reasoning:
Your eyes resist itYou don't want to keep watching this movie. After wincing at some of the issues I mention below for a while, I was prepared to tell my friend he didn't need to pay me back for the ticket. During the last third I actually couldn't watch a few scenes because I was embarrassed for everyone in the movie. Scenes that should have had huge emotional impact - Luke reuniting with Leah, Luke reuniting with R2 - were wasted and barely registered. They wanted us to go"Awwww" but they phoned it in. I confirmed with my friend that at a certain point, you actually feel like you are enduring the movie.
You don't care about the charactersThey set up some nice characters in the previous film. Supreme Leader Snope was menacing and mysterious, but lost all the mystique in person. Finn was this unique turncoat Storm Trooper, and in this movie he becomes a two-dimensional "Whoo-hoo!" action hero. Other characters haven't been sufficiently rounded out for you to care about them (the silvery Captain Phasma and purple-haired Vice Admiral Holdo, most prominently). And don't get me started on the totally unconvincing and overpromoted red-haired boss General Hux, who is neither "bad guy" nor comic relief.
The dialogue is awfulThere were lots of moments for great one liners: every second with Luke or Leia, when Rey and Kylo have their telepathy conference calls, and certainly with Snope.
But there's nothing memorable said in the movie at all. Really - what lines did you find yourself quoting afterward?
Rey: You're a monster.
Kylo: Yes, I am.
Luke: I failed you, Ben. I'm sorry.
Kylo: I'm sure you are! The Resistance is dead, the war is over, and when I kill you, I will have killed the last Jedi!
This sounds like bad high school writing, of which I am very familiar. There's also whatever forgettable dialogue happened between Rose and Finn during the end of the flick as well.
It doesn't inspire.
It punches holes in itselfThe movie makes a few huge mistakes that greatly impact the entire Star Wars universe.
Lightspeed Attack - First, I have been saying to anyone who will listen for the past 10 years that Star Wars did a good job of not including an obvious flaw with Lightspeed Technology: That's it's clearly the best weapon ever. Why bother to send a huge Star Destroyer against a transport ship when a tiny escape pod can reach lightspeed and blow it apart? But it appeared this was scientifically impossible, which gave way to the amazing space battles we all know and love.
But in this movie, when Vice Admiral Holdo lightspeeds her ship through the enemy fleet, it clearly was possible all along.
So they are saying no one ever thought of this before? (And I'll leave aside why, if there are only 50 rebels left alive, they would sacrifice a VICE ADMIRAL on that suicide run).
But there's even a bigger plothole revealed here. Most science says that a ship traveling at lightspeed would have almost limitless mass. That's enough to destroy... a whole planet. Why build a Death Star, exactly?
It's raining Jedis - In the Star Wars Universe, Jedis are clearly a big deal. Their name evokes feelings of great respect and fear, and the Jedi Council basically functioned as high-caste Samurai in powerful leadership roles. And their abilities, of course, are devastating. So the loss of Jedi Masters is seen as a loss to the universe, a dimming of goodness throughout the entire galaxy. Why else are Snope and Kylo so interested in killing Luke - the "Last Jedi?" Why else did they invent those awful midichlorians but to show how rare Jedi powers were?
But Luke here reveals that the Force really does touch everyone, and that the potential for there to be lots more Jedis (infinite Jedis?). If that's the case, then it's like all those rare Jedis turned out to be as common as Dixie Cups. If the Force as a resource is widespread, it devalues all of the movies and makes the deaths of all other Jedis to be much more meh. This was hugely destructive.
Not so stealthy - Unless I am incorrect, the movie suddenly introduces "cloaking technology." This is a huge technological achievement that transforms the nature of every space battle. Even if we allow that this technology was invited in the 30 years since the end of Return of The Jedi, why isn't it ubiquitous? Why doesn't the newly rebranded Empire with limitless resources have it? Why do only the Lesser Codebreaker and the Escape Shuttles have them?
Stealth technology might have been a good thing to put on those bombers at the beginning of the film, hmmm?
U-Turn - The entire giant subplot with Finn and Rose and the fate of the fleet was to stop the tracking device on the Star Destroyer. But they never destroyed the tracking device, so their entire jaunt to the Casino and the Codebreak was a meaningless detour.
Wimpy in Red - Of course I loved seeing the ninja Crimson Guard commanders fight Kylo and Ren. Until... it occurred to me that ninjas don't have any powers. Kylo could have mopped them up in three seconds and gotten back to moping.
All of these faults sting even more because of this final point:
They had time to make it perfectDisney had this incredible body of work, an effectively unlimited budget, and access to any actors or actresses they possibly needed (included beloved originals like Mark Hamill and Carrie Fisher). They also had their pick of the best writers and cinematographers. But even more importantly, they learned from the awful Prequels what NOT to do.
And yet here we are.
In summary, even the minor bright spots (good effects, diverse cast, the return of Yoda, Daisy in every scene) couldn't make up for these lapses.
It hurts me to say, but this movie is such garbage that it belongs in the trash compactor from Episode IV.
Maybe Star Wars was never supposed to be for adults. Maybe it's become a kids movie and I had no business watching it.
It did leave with one big question to ponder: Am I a good parent if I show this movie to my kids?